McConaughey, Fallon fail to acknowledge struggles of Austin living
Late night talk show host Jimmy Fallon of “The Tonight Show” came to Texas last week, visiting Austin and hosting a show from The University of Texas at Austin on Nov 7.
Fallon turned “The Tonight Show” into a momentous celebration of Austin and UT spirit by incorporating country music numbers, paying three UT student’s tuition, and interviewing UT’s Minister of Culture, Matthew McConaughey.
It wasn’t until a couple of minutes into this speech that I wondered if we lived in the same Austin.
“One of the great things about Austin is to make it here, all you really gotta do is be yourself,” McConaughey said. “You can be a cowboy, you can be a hippie, you can be an American Indian, you can be an Asian, Lesbian, White, Black, Brown, Yellow – a blue-haired dwarf and you are welcome in Austin! You really are!”
With that logic, you would think that homeless people and low-income students should be included in this welcoming, but they aren’t.
State agencies started to move in last week in an effort to “clean up” Austin and its homeless problem. The homeless population of
Austin has suffered a major hit these past few months following the orders of Gov. Greg Abbott to intervene with Austin City Council and wipe out multiple homeless encampments. This not only went against Austin City Council’s ordinance that made homeless camping legal, but it set up a growing community of thousands of homeless residents for potential danger. With a cold winter moving in, Abbott is freezing the homeless population out of Austin.
“What I think unites all this diversity I was talking about, is that we have a cowboy code and a sense of common values that we all rally behind,” McConaughey said. “ In Austin, nobody’s too good … but everybody’s good enough.”
Additionally, the City of Austin voted in early October to knock down five affordable student apartments, which include Ballpark North, Town Lake, and Quad East, West and South and replace them with 4,700 family units, 600 hotel rooms and more than 4 million square feet of office and retail space. This leaves low-income students and single-year renters without a home starting in 2023. I don’t see how some of Austin’s only affordable student housing being demolished for luxury condos couldn’t have been mentioned during a taping on a college campus in Austin.
If you’re reading this and asking yourself, “does this guy really expect McConaughey to speak out about these issues on national television?” My answer to you is yes.
McConaughey is no stranger to protests. This is apparent in his appearance at the March For Our Lives rally last summer, where he called Texas lawmakers to pass common sense gun legislation. Him being there not only gained national attention, but cemented his authority as an Austinite to the greater public.
When you have an influential person like McConaughey go on national television and tell the world what a great place Austin is, you are undermining the problems that run rampant in our city.
“We don’t lie, cheat and steal, we’re an optimistic people, we’re resilient, we’re friendly, we’re fair, we respect and value ourselves and we respect and value each other,” McConaughey said.
I understand that there’s a time and place for everything. There’s time to celebrate campus culture and there’s time to shed light on injustice. But with ACL in the past and SXSW still months away, this episode of “The Tonight Show” felt like an impulse that gave Austin a pat on the back for seemingly no reason.
Mind you, I’m not even going into the thousands of microaggressions that students of color face everyday in Austin. Nor am I going into the historic racist underbelly that Austin was (literally) built on. You all can find that out for yourselves.
What I will say is that when it comes to white men in power, even if they are as cool as McConaughey, it’s absolutely necessary to take what they say with a grain of salt. Austin is not a hippie town that is filled with love for every neighbor, and it’s downright negligent for people like McConaughey to give that idea to the millions of viewers of “The Tonight Show.” In short, Austin has some ways to go before McConaughey can deem it “alright, alright, alright,” to a mass audience.
Perhaps McConaughey put it best when he said, “to all newcomers — you know we got 125 a day coming here – if you don’t want to come here and respect our values and our tradition please keep on flying, drive on by.”
I'm Matthew San Martin - A senior Communication major with a focus in Digital Media and Journalism and Editor-in-Chief of Hilltop Views. I served as News...
P.. Owerwhiteman • Nov 26, 2019 at 11:45 pm
Well written and nice very black full head of hair.
Privilege and abuse of power comes in all colors and genders…
Natalie Ford • Nov 14, 2019 at 1:45 pm
This town is founded on lies upon lies. I moved here in 2000 and attended UT. While obtaining my English degree I worked as a nanny. Once I completed my degree I continued to work as a career nanny. I worked for some of the most powerful people in this town. These people did not care when I had health problems, or if I could not afford health insurance. Just like McConaughey, they pretended like everything was great for everyone. It’s called Narcissism and it effects Liberals just as often as Conservatives.
Elly Call • Nov 14, 2019 at 1:06 pm
This was a great article—keep it up!!
Jason Conrey • Nov 14, 2019 at 11:25 am
There are “struggles to living” in any major city; this is just one more example of the “poor me” society we seem to be coddling these days. Travel more, then tell me Austin doesn’t deserve the “pat on the back”, during a portion of a televised program in which the point was to praise our city.
Get over yourself, or move.
Delbert Johnston • Nov 14, 2019 at 10:43 am
How many homeless people have you taken in Matthew San Martin? Matthew McConaughey is proud of Austin. How about you be proud also and see the good Austin has to offer instead of focusing on the negative? By the way, I don’t like the way you part your hair!
Robert Brown • Nov 14, 2019 at 8:43 am
This article is exactly why after 26 years of living there, I left. You may have 125 a day coming there, but all the people that made it what it is are dying or leaving. Non-Austinites writing about Austinites needs. Good job.
Charlotte Labots • Nov 14, 2019 at 7:24 am
Great Article! I’m tired of these actors giving false views. We had one in Oregon say best place to retire, drove our prices up and then crash people were losing their homes. Diversity with human morals is required, not freedom to look strange on your own accord being something that makes a city awesome!!?? We need to be a city of we take care of those in NEED! Not just come here just to wear what skin you feel like today! Let’s get past superficial things like looks and sexuality and let’s focus on “PEOPLE” who need jobs, food clothes and homes!
John.Buckner • Nov 14, 2019 at 4:54 am
thank you for enlightening me.
Jon • Nov 14, 2019 at 1:27 am
You really want to knock these entertainers about their lack of empathy for the low income or homeless in Austin? I will bet nickels to dollars these two evil entertainers have done more for the needy than you or organization has done.
Does Austin have challenges? Yes. 100% we agree!
Blasting a couple of entertainers that love Austin and can bring some positive light and attention to our great city is only serving to grab headlines and bring traffic to your silly blog.
Help the city. Help find a solution. Profile the people who want to be positive and bring progress. We have enough negativity, I guarantee you that everyone in Bass Concert Hall that night would agree we all want to find a solution. There is a time and place.
Keep up the good work and inspire us, don’t criticize us for having a good time and celebrating what Austin means.
D Miller • Nov 13, 2019 at 11:03 pm
Thank you for the article you said it right I like some of the changes in Austin but a lot of it is hurting our city and the city I love and grew up in I no longer can relate to and I never thought I would say it but thinking about leaving but when I see that sky line of the city I cannt think of any place that would be better than Austin
Gracie solis • Nov 13, 2019 at 10:52 pm
Your article touched me because as a native austinite, I’ve seen austin transform in more bad ways than good. The problems people face living here only affect people of color more than their white counterparts. People can’t afford to live here and the city leaders and our wonderful governor just don’t get it. We keep pushing out in every way possible. It’s sad how the city is growing but leaving a large portion of the population out.
Johng • Nov 13, 2019 at 9:44 pm
Every large city has a homeless problem. Every college town has low income students. No need for him to go on a captain obvious rant. Every where has racism, poverty, infrastructure issues. Segregation by income is necessary. I don’t want to improve my life and financial status and live in high crime areas. And this is irrelevant of race. All races and economic groups have opportunities. I grew up very poor, changing schools frequently and live pretty well now. I made life choices despite my circumstances and people of all races, colors and nationalities have done the same. This episode wasn’t the time or place to discuss these issues. Bet you’re fun at parties.
Henry Nguyen • Nov 13, 2019 at 9:21 pm
Not everything has to be a protest, I don’t think the tonight show would do very well if you were left in charge of the segments
Jan • Nov 13, 2019 at 6:35 pm
Hey, San Martin, you got it wrong, W-A-A-A-Y wrong. I’ve lived here for the last 50 years, and McConaughey is spot on. Many of the homeless you talk about are out-of-towners, they bus here to weather the winter in warmer climate, sort of like hobo snowbirds. They decide where to go via the underground, something you seem clueless about. If you give freebies, they’ll arrive by the thousands. I’m not heartless, just well informed. CA already has that problem, Thank Goodness Abbot is just helping to stem the tide. We don’t need more street campers here. BTW, I DO care. I’ve taken food and clothes out to the homeless, paid hotels to put them up during freezing rain, and helped out in the soup kitchen. Why don’t do that yourself for the ones in your neck of the woods and spare Austin the health hazard you seem to promote.
James Puglisi • Nov 13, 2019 at 6:16 pm
As a white Christian male of privilege, I found this a very Good write-up, speaking directly to the issues of white privilege in Austin, gentrification, systemic racism, homelessness, police brutality…well, the list goes one. It is a very selective memory of Austin’s history on McConaughey’s part, absolutely from the lens of white privilege. It is a lens that is shared even by those who would regard themselves as “progressive”.
Linda grajek • Nov 13, 2019 at 6:02 pm
I disagree with your premise that the aforementioned meeting should have included the issue of the homeless. Austin is dealing with this problem (no thanks to the city council) by people rallying to spend tax dollars to purchase hotels and apartments for the homeless. I have no problem with spending my tax money or giving money to charities that help the poor. But I do not want drug addicts and those not willing to work to sit around with their hand out asking for free stuff. I see many you people begging for money on street corners. I drug addicts smoking pot in street corners. I have seen others selling drugs to the homeless. If you have money to buy cigarettes, liquor or drugs you should get treatment or quit smoking and contribute to those who are sick or disabled. Alcoholism and drug addiction is treatable, join AA or NA. They do it for free and have meetings every where. Their success rate is high. Stop enabling the homeless and give them a reason to change.
Lonnie • Nov 13, 2019 at 5:22 pm
I too feel that this was a missed opportunity to bring the issue and need of housing for low income and the homeless. Apparently it is about the tax revenues and not the need of the people. But I’m sure if you dig
deeper you will find major tax breaks for theses developers. Leaving homeowners to pick up the slack in property tax. Where is the extra emergency services going to come from. More growth means more expenses. Less for the ones that need help. If no lower income housing, means more homeless.
Don’t do like Calif.
Tina Cheatham • Nov 13, 2019 at 5:20 pm
Most of the homeless, choose that way of life, because a lot is givin to them.
On the other hand there is disabled, old, or situations that may have happened in life the result a roof over your head, is no longer shelter it’s hope to survive, resourceful word of advice or a direction to have a better your tomorrow.
Dylan • Nov 13, 2019 at 5:03 pm
I agree with your sentiment, but that’s a big claim when you say that about white men. I’m a Bernie supporter and believe that there still is a good amount of white men, but unfortunately those in power don’t fit this bill. Otherwise, thanks for the opinion and the good read!
Q • Nov 13, 2019 at 5:02 pm
Well written and articulated article
Karen • Nov 13, 2019 at 4:12 pm
It is sad when you turn on the TV or read a news article and all you hear is about the bad things happening around our city. I found it uplifiing when McConaughey pointed out the positives. By living here we enjoy our multi faceted town however the people that don’t have nowhere to learn about it because good things seldomly make the news.
Thank you Matthew!
James Osburn • Nov 13, 2019 at 3:57 pm
I love or loved Austin but its affordable and the rising rent pushed me out and so many of the things I loved (Vulcan Video).
Sue • Nov 13, 2019 at 3:42 pm
Matthew,
I think you bring up many good points and you do it in such a nice way. In my opinion, I don’t expect McConoughay and Fallon to bring attention to the homeless issue. The other night they did their jobs very well entertaining their audience.
The issue of the homeless is serious. I would have never imagined that in this time period we would have as many homeless people in Austin and in so many other places in the United States. We the people should not tolerate homelessness and should find a solution.
What can we do? I welcome what the state is currently doing, at the same time I am going to continue to vote for the council people who have good hearts and continue to try their best to find solutions.
Matthew, I applaud you for writing this opinion page. I hope more people read this. I hope that you not only will write the write, but walk the walk and go out and use your voice to find some solutions.
Steve Cook • Nov 13, 2019 at 3:25 pm
Well said, Matthew! I agree with you that it is up to all of us, including “high profile” Austinites to celebrate our diversity but to also advocate for greater equality and affordable housing.
antonio • Nov 13, 2019 at 3:25 pm
So, many people don’t know Austin’s history. The ban on camping was implemented in the 90’s when Austin was very closed door and did not want people to move here. They wanted the city to be small and clean, which I understand most do not want the homeless population. They are a drag on the city and frankly chose to be homeless and not provide anything useful.
Rhonda • Nov 13, 2019 at 1:52 pm
That isnt his job to speak of the homeless issues in our city. He was there to speak about UT and other things there. Jimmy fallon is not the place for that. If he was being interviewed on a news station or some other platform, then yes. Everyone is welcome here, but you cant just brush them under the rug like Gov Abbott want too. Maybe he should be the one you direct your snark remarks towards. Hebis thenone that initiated all this. Not matthew.
Danny • Nov 13, 2019 at 1:09 pm
You know what Matthew, you’re onto something. Next time Jimmy Fallon does his show in a new city he should invite some citizens to come onto the stage and say everything bad about the city he’s visiting. Good idea. The first thing that I want to do as a citizen of Austin is to come home from the 9 to 5 and hear about how crappy my city is. Leave the dumb political stuff to the news and Twitter.
Noah • Nov 13, 2019 at 12:48 pm
You mentioned austins racist issues but then make a racist comment about white men at the end of the article. Please do some thinking on that.
Karenbeth Glunz • Nov 13, 2019 at 12:47 pm
Having Mr. McConaughey be a spoke person for Austin, is insane.
He is a celebrity.
He doesn’t live a “normal” life when his finances include millions of dollars.
I wish he would stick to acting and stop making Austin sound so attractive so more people move here.
I am a 75 year old senior on a limited budget and I can assure you, Austin is becoming another Houston, expanding, expanding, and expanding with 800 cars moving here PER WEEK!
Let Mr. McConaughey run for office…sit on the city council, or do something besides spout ridiculousness.
Geesh!
Tom Oliver • Nov 13, 2019 at 10:13 am
60 years have passed since I arrived in Austin in January, 1960 to enroll in my 3rd university in 3 years. Only modestly aided (due to past modest accomplishments) by my parents, I moved in with a old high school friend and 2 other room mates. A 4 of us had modest funds available, in my case enough for registration, fees, and books for 2 years, enough to graduate. I had a part time job which paid $35.00 a week and a small car. I and my room mates lives frugally, watching every dollar. Our apartment at 33rd and Grooms, just off Duval, was modest (although Ben Barnes, married and selling vacuum cleaners, did live downstairs, not yet in “high cotton”) with a monthly rent of $100 “”+ bills”.
Harsh reality? Today, the 4 of us could no longer afford to attend the University, no longer afford to live in Austin, and would have been likely to have missed out on some of the accomplishments 3 of us made in our later working lives. As for the 4th, some bad choices shortened his legal career, but that’s another tale. “Weird” may be fun, but it’s upon “Affordable” that the present was built (and upon which the future may depend).
Tim Irvine • Nov 13, 2019 at 8:00 am
In the thirty years I have lived in Austin I have observed some very positive things, like the improving food scene and more “big city” amenities, but I have observed more situations where we have simply failed to do the things we really need to do. Clearly funding and providing the resources to address homelessness and the affordability, mental health, and substance abuse issues that often accompany it is still aspirational. Our horrendous traffic situation will require an expensive and time-consuming solution as most of our roads are simply inadequate. We have very few east-west arterials, our north-south arterials cannot expand without displacing things, and we have no loop(s). We have gentrification and rising property taxes colliding with the east side and displacing long time residents. We have a legacy of segregation that persists and educational inequality that is deeply disturbing. The sort of friendliness Matthew described can certainly be found, but it does not always extend to the “other.” We are a cool city with a lot of positive things, but in many ways we lag behind other large cities in mustering the collective will to address our systemic flaws.